So we had to do something. When I asked him what kind of cake he wanted, he said, "Birthday!" "No. What kind of birthday cake?" "Blue!" he said. I was a little confused. "Like Blue's Clues? You want a Blue's Clues birthday cake?" "No! Blue cake!" So we had blue cake. A little gross, if you ask me, but he thought it was great. We sang Happy Birthday twice, with Evan leading us both times, and he blew out the candles twice. He had trouble opening the presents, but his friends and cousins and siblings were happy to help with that.
Here are some pictures, so you can better imagine the fun and craziness.